Flutiebear: Rambling My Way Through Thedas

I’d say probably an aggro, pro-Templar Hawke would classify as a Dictator archetype. A few of the more typical characteristics of this personality include:

• An obsession to control, dictate and rule over others — someone who thinks fear is more powerful than love
• Judgmental and a harsh, unforgiving wielder of justice (and justice is whatever he/she says it is)
• Creates meaningless rules and laws just to have something to lord over his or her compatriots
• Places no value on family responsibility or duty. Often absent from family life. Does whatever the hell he/she wants without regard to siblings or parents

You get the point. She’d be arrogant and painfully hypocritical, considering that a Mage Marian still hails from a magical background, and there’s a certain kind of marvelous tragedy about it all, but augh, what a punch to the gut it would be, right?

Personally, I see Anders as a cross between the Messiah/Punisher and The Artist/Abuser archetypes, which when paired with a Dictator would inevitably lead to a rivalmance (quite a dramatic one, in fact).

As far as Fenris goes, he’s probably a a Protector/Gladiator type, and he’d naturally gravitate to a Dictator as someone to protect (hence the friendmance). He’d probably struggle a lot more with a Diplo!Hawke (who probably more closely fits the Nurturer or King archetype than the Dictator).